Yahoo! Services

Account Options

New User? Sign Up Sign In Help

Yahoo! Search

Music Blogs

If She...

Posted Wed Oct 15, 2008 11:51am PDT by Jordan Gracey in Reality Bites

Alright y’all, don’t shoot the messenger!

 

Let me just say that I like Beyoncé!  I think she’s a great performer, talented actress, savvy business woman and easy on the eyes.  I also respect how she doesn’t use the paparazzi to stay current, rather she relies on her artistry.  She's a total class act!

 

With that being said….

 

As you may already know, Beyoncé’s third solo album I Am… is due to drop November 18th.  Last week, her video for the lead track “If I Were A Boy” hit various media channels and was met with rave reviews and pleased fans everywhere.

 

However, grumblings also began that this song doesn’t belong to Beyoncé.  Before I jumped on the bandwagon I decided to do some digging and discover if this was real or rumour (‘cause we all know that for every fan there are at least a half dozen haters right?). 

 

My findings:

Song credits for If I Were a Boy” are stated as Toby Gad and Beyoncé Knowles on Wikipedia.  (I had to check here as the album isn’t actually out yet).  After this I turned to iTunes…no luck.  The single isn’t up for sale yet, nor is the video.  Darn.  No fear, the Internet is a vast place, I was sure to find something else.   What did I find?  “If I Were A Boy,” recorded by a little 21 year-old who goes by the name of BC Jean

This California native is apparently the next generation star, from a musical family that has been associated with RCA Records.  For those of you not familiar with labels, RCA (or RCA Victor) is one of the flagship labels of Sony.  Beyoncé is signed to Columbia, which is now a premier subsidiary label of Sony.  Hmmmm...... 

Check it for yourself here 

 

Sorry B!

Jay, please don’t come after me!

What do you guys make of this?

249 Comments

161. Ruby -
perfecto

162. Yahoo! Music User -
both versions sound the same i like beyonce;s voice with this sound better though and i think that she's too professional to just take someone else's song like that her career is already i don't think that she needs to stoop to this level the bc had to give her permission to use the song meaning that she was paid for it otherwise that would be a big lawsuit waiting to happen and this bc has family music connections so why hasn't she been in the mainstream she's in the headlines now maybe that's what she wanted from this whole situation

163. andrew c -
here is my prediction.
Beyonce probably did steal the song , or someone attached to her camp did(that's probably going to be the official story, " that person has been fired...blah blah blah"). The way this usually works is ,the big artist wants to record the little artists song. The little artist says "no, sorry, this is one of my best songs , I really want to release it myself" . Big artist says " don't you know who i am, don't you know how much publicity you will get if i do your song?". Little artist says "yeah, but i don't want to be known as a songwriter for beyonce , our styles are completely different, so, the answer is still no". Big artist says" well I'm going to record it anyway...sue me if you want". To save face beyonce is going to say , B C Jean sold her the song and has been compensated fully , or, a grievous clerical error prevented B C from getting the credit she deserves...and you know what ? B C Jean will go along with whatever the story is, 'cause that's the way the game is played.

164. davemaryannh... -
i like beyonce's version much much better, but i agree with EDWAY9, why would she take a sone from someone else? Both are amaZing singers (bc,b) they both are pretty and taented but it was low to steel someones song expesally the fact she did not ask! y would she do something so mean its bcs song i say she keep it, but it does sound better on beyonce! i like bs vidio better 2. but ether way its bcs song she has a right to sing it not beyonce!!!

165. faith -
can u people leave the pretty girl alone she is mentor

faith from ghana

166. tiggrific -
Have just heard the original and have to agree with the majority...the original by BC is WAY better.
Looking forward to the album.....

167. __A_YAHOO_USER__ -
Beyonce paid this BC Jean girl for rights to her song, so therefore it belongs to Beyonce now. Do more research before you write stuff.

168. DALKEITH Y -
I am black as tar but BC Jean's version sounds much, much better than Knowles'. The truth bites.

169. Yahoo! Music User -
BC Jean's version has more "punch" to it. She sounds incredible. I hope she's the winner in this mess.

170. randy_hst -
In this day and age of rapid internet communication, I hardly would think that Bouncee with her current successful carrer and intelligence is attempting plagiarism.
I mean c'mon, it is obviously BC's song and who knows, maybe BC won a "make me and my song famous overnight" contest and has something worked out with Bouncee.

171. archivalk -
A prime example of life imitating art! Anyone remember what Beyoncé's character did on to Jennifer Hudson's character on Dream Girls?

172. RENEE -
I like BC's version much better too.

173. Gerry P -
Doesn't matter who's version is better. The point is that Beyonce is claiming she wrote the song.

174. josi -
Original version is really good! I've read that BC Jean was a version and didn't want to use it (not so sure about this) and decided to sell the song to Beyoncé... Both version are great.

175. Joji -
This Calls for a BAN............

176. Yahoo! Music User -
BC's version is waaaaaaay better! I can't stand the way Beyonce wine's her way through the song...

177. Yahoo! Music User -
yeh bc's version is waaaay better. sorry b..

178. Tammy A -
I actually like BC Jean's version better. It's more heartfelt, not so commercial. And I'm a Beyonce fan, so...from the mouthes of babes. Sorry Beyonce....

179. CHAPMAN -
Is nothing sacred anymore. Shameful!

180. __A_YAHOO_USER__ -
Everyone just naturally assumes that Beyonce stole the song. Have you heard the whole story? So you know if the song was sold? Has Beyonce's album come out yet listing Beyonce as the songs writer? If you don't like her fine, just make sure it is for something she has actually done, before you roast her in the fire pit. I don't hear BC Jean coming out and complaining, what till the actual facts come out people.
Page:  5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 
Leave Your Comment
You must sign in to leave a comment
Select a Blog Posts
New This Week
by Dave DiMartino
123
Reality Bites
by Jordan Gracey
38
Reality Rocks
by Lyndsey Parker
579
Rock's Backpages
by Philip Norman (1970)
191
Sound Check
by Yahoo! Music Canada
27
Stop The Presses!
by Us Magazine
85
That's Really Week
by Lyndsey Parker
124
The Blender Burner
by Blender Magazine
27
The MOJO Blog
by Bill DeMain
88
The NME Blog
by Luke Lewis
48
The Spin Blog
by David Marchese
77
The Ten
by Andy West
9
Video Ga Ga
by Lyndsey Parker
70

Music Blog Archives

Lambert says he got carried away, but not sorry

AP
Wed Nov 25, 2009 11:00am PST

AP - Adam Lambert admits he got carried away with his sexually charged American Music Awards performance, but he's offering no apology. The glam rocker from "American Idol" said on "The Early Show" t… More »

More News Stories