Yahoo! Services

Account Options

New User? Sign Up Sign In Help

Yahoo! Search

Music Blogs

10 Endless Songs

Posted Fri Apr 24, 2009 1:10pm PDT by Rob O'Connor in List Of The Day
Sure, I could've put half the ELP and Yes catalog on this list, but those bands don't often get much airplay these days. And that's true for Rush as well, who I almost put on the list for "2112" and then couldn't think of the last time I'd heard it in a social setting. Same for Jethro Tull's "Thick As A Brick" and Bob Dylan's "Sad Eyed Lady Of The Lowlands."

In order to qualify for this list, the song had to be something that the radio has insisted on playing to some degree. That's why Canned Heat got canned. No one plays their records anymore on the radio. But I've heard these others from time to time. They may not be the longest songs ever recorded. But they do make you feel like your time on earth has been lasting like one long Monday morning.

10) "Stairway To Heaven"--Led Zeppelin: OK, I liked this song the first two thousand times I heard it. It builds nicely and I love hearing about the bustle in the hedgerow. But sitting in a public place and hearing that introduction kick in immediately sets off the alarm bells: must get stiff drink!

9) "Freebird"--Lynyrd Skynyrd: DJs can't leave well enough alone and insist on playing the live version of this song which includes about ten too many piano runs and fake endings, as if the interminable jam preceding it hadn't already wrecked the good feeling of the first four minutes of the song.

8) "Sympathy For The Devil"--The Rolling Stones: The Rolling Stones usually get it done in three minutes. Here, they decide to give us a history lesson where we somehow get blamed for killing the Kennedys. This song absolutely kicks in its live incarnation, but the studio track with its special percussion and "ooh ooh" chants is like one of those moments when you start thumbing ahead to see where the chapter ends and you realize it still has about four pages without pictures before you're done. Too much work.

7) "Rosalita"--Bruce Springsteen: "Jungleland" would go here if they played it more. But "Rosalita" seems to be the endless Bruce song of choice for DJs who have to use the toilet. I know this blog has picked on him quite a bit, and you might start to think I don't like the guy. It's not that. There are many fine moments. It's just that the ones that keep coming back at you are always the corniest ones. And songs about being in a rock n' roll band are always by definition corny. It's a little too self-aware.

6) "Hey Jude"--The Beatles: Anyone who doesn't feel like gouging out their eyes after a minute of that damned "na-na" part of the song is either a very simple person or someone who should consider stuffing envelopes for a living. You like monotony.

5) "The End"--The Doors: "Lost in a roman wilderness of pain." Is that where we are, Jim? Sometimes this tune hits the spot, but other times it's like "Get me off this blue bus and hurry!" He keeps saying it's the end, but it takes eleven minutes to get there. Stop procrastinating!

4) "Whipping Post"--The Allman Brothers Band: If you've ever sat in a bar wondering what you're doing there and this song comes on, it's like the universe is mocking you. This isn't even their longest tune, but it's the one DJs are under the mistaken impression that we want to hear yet again. Supposedly, people today have shorter attention spans. Can we have a three minute edit?

3) "Shine On You Crazy Diamond"--Pink Floyd: I admit I heard this once on the Weather Channel while getting my "Local On The 8s" and it was a big improvement over that crap they call "jazz" that usually plays while you learn about the fine particles in the air. But heard on the radio when you're in a rush to get somewhere, the song actually makes you and everyone else drive slower.

2) "In-A-Gadda-Da-Vida"--Iron Butterfly: They've phased this one out as old hippies keep dying off and maybe "Suite:Judy Blue Eyes" should take its place, but this is twice as long and features a phased drum solo that entertains no one. But it's broken out every once in awhile as evidence that long songs once ruled the earth. Beats having to hear "Alice's Restaurant" on Thanksgiving, but that's not saying much.

1) "Dazed And Confused"--Led Zeppelin: The studio version is slow and plodding but the live version is so interminable that you're convinced that you're actually waiting for Jimmy Page to go find his bow before the guitar solo takes off. Twenty-plus minutes later and it's STILL going on. Who thought this was a good idea? If you see this available on your local bar's jukebox, do yourself a favor and program it just as you're leaving. Sit out in the parking lot and see how long it takes to clear the joint.

Get Iron Butterfly, The Allman Brothers Band and Bruce Springsteen tickets here.

51 Comments

1. Yahoo! Music User -
Derek and the Dominos, "Layla".........Yaaaaawn.

2. L Cobain -
i was just waiting to see the bohemian rhapsody by queen up there. disappointment!

3. DavidN -
i agree, Bohemian Rhapsody is an endurance test. how about Bittersweet by Big Head Todd? probably not the longest song on this list but certainly one of the most boring.. Yawn!

4. cmd51375 -
what about "hotel california"by the eagles,i mean its a good song(one of my favs),but the end of that song just seems to go on and on and on... well you get my drift.

5. __A_YAHOO_USER__ -
Haha, endless indeed. Though Stairway is still good. I don't listen to the radio, so I can't say what would qualify...

Though modern rock radio sounds like one huge generic composition. Then I learn they just played 20 artists. Who knew 20 artists could sound like cheap imitations of Nickelback, a cheap imitation itself!

6. Evan B -
Solid list Rob, songs the average music fan knows!!! The underground is cool if your an unemployed 20 something with a chemical dependency problem!!!

5.American Pie(Don Mclean) Why the satanic verses?
4.Green Grass & High Tides(Outlaws) Send Nashville a copy
3.Rhyme of the Ancient Mariner(Iron Maiden) Metal Scholars
2.Tobacco Road(Edgar Winter) 1970's excess at it's best
1.Alice's Restaurant Massacree(Arlo Guthrie) Closed

7. DUDE -
99 Bottles Of Beer On The Wall......

8. cmd51375 -
unknown musician54,i agree with you about "layla" to a point,the 1st half of the song was totally kick ass,its when you get to the 2nd half of the song(particularly the piano/guitar combo solo)that's where the song really starts to drag.i mean once you're at that part of the song you're thinking "i'd give anything for this song to end" and please don't get me started on the unplugged version of this song,i mean some songs are good unplugged(ie great white's rendition of "babe i'm gonna leave you"on mtv unplugged in may of 1990).the unplugged version of the song in 1992 almost totally destroyed that song.the reason being that "layla" is a very intense and powerful,dare i say,love song and the electric version reflects that in eric clapton's delivery of the lyrics in that his singing is very intense,powerful and emotional.the unplugged version on the otherhand chooses a very restrained delivery,which emasuclates the intensity and power of the original.

9. SALVADOR -
Good. But U know what other songs drag? Boston's "Don't Look Back",the Eagles' "Hotel California" and Jimi Hendrix's "Voodoo Chile". Oh my God, that last one is 15 minutes! But still good songs!

10. SALVADOR -
Another one, the Doors' "Riders on the Storm" . I mean, he only sings, like , 2 verses and the song is 7 minutes long!

11. Yahoo! Music User -
cmd51375, I totally agree with you. The first part of the song is excellent, especially Duane Allman's slide guitar. If they had ended it earler, this song would have never been mentioned by me. It is a great song, until the boring part. You made an excellent point!

12. cmd51375 -
here are another couple of songs that kind of seem to drag on:the live versions of the who's "my generation" and "magic bus" particularly the live at leeds versions from 1970,i mean the leeds version of "magic bus" runs at about 10 minutes and the leeds version "my generation" runs at about 15 minutes(although i have heard from some sources that the song when played live sometimes could run a lot longer),now dont get me wrong,live at leeds is probably one of the best live albums i've ever heard,i mean its just one great song after another and there aren't too many long speeches between songs,also it has by far the best live version of "tommy".now someone on this post mentioned the beatles"hey jude"and i agree with that,i mean it does seem to run a bit long,however i don't know if anyone has ever seen the video for that song,but when they got to the end,everyone in the audience at the video joined in and sang along with it perhaps one of the most amazing i've ever seen.now here's another beatles song that tends to run on is "i want you(she's so heavy)",however what redeems that for me is the intensity and power of the music throughout that song.now the beatles have normally have had the sense to distill a song to its essence,take "helter skelter"for example,some reports had that song running at about 30 min,however the beatles were able to take out the best 4 min of that and hence you have one of the reasons why i crank up my cd player as loud as i can whenever i hear that song.i particularly love the end of that song when ringo shouts out "i've got blisters on my fingers"

13. G -
All these songs are great, hence why they are never ending. They wouldn't be never ending if people got sick of them. Gouging out eyeballs seems unnecessary.

14. cmd51375 -
point taken gcap222,i mean after all the beatles"hey jude"had to have had something to it considering it was the beatles biggest number one hit in the us,as well as having the distinction of being billboard's song of the year for 1968(thus making the beatles one of the few multi-time billboard song of the year recipents).i mean that and iron butterfly's song are the song number 1 songs on this list,so obviously people couldn't have been that sick of these songs if they bought enough copies to make these songs number 1.also the iron butterfly title(in case you weren't aware)came about when they famously mispronounced garden of eden.you know that song actually took up 1 side of their debut album.i'm aware that some people may be aware of these facts,however there are some people who read these who may not be aware of them.so hopefully people can read this and perhaps learn something they didn't already know.

15. cmd51375 -
salvador read comment number 4,because i did mention that song way before you did

16. SALVADOR -
Yeah, I did (his daughter,BTW) but U are right, it's a good song.

17. pha-q-did -
Edmond Fitzgerld (Gordon Lightfoot)...I find myself wishing I could go down with the ship everytime its on.

18. Matthew -
this is an awful list there is nothing better, than dazed and confused (my itunes has me listening to the live version over 80 times, 30 minutes long), stairway to heaven (argueably the greatest song ever written, also is the most requested song on the radio in the US without ever being released as a single, 3rd greatest song ever by Rolling stone, 2nd greatest solo ever by rolling stone, not to meniton what it did for music in general), and freebird (lynyrd skynyrd's most impressive guitar work) are songs that will never get old and i wish they really were endless i could listen to those songs forever

19. Karen -
Played at most wedding receptions to get the crowd dancing, Billy Idol's "Mony Mony" NEVER seems to end!!!

Now, THIS is a song that I love, but Fleetwood Mac's "Oh Well" is like "Layla" in the sense of a kick-butt beginning, then a very long, mellow ending.

20. Yahoo! Music User -
Glad to see Stairway on the list. Definitely the most overrated song ever. Not saying it's bad, but it's just not THAT good.
Page:  1 | 2 | 3 
Leave Your Comment
You must sign in to leave a comment
Select a Blog Posts
New This Week
by Dave DiMartino
123
Reality Bites
by Jordan Gracey
38
Reality Rocks
by Lyndsey Parker
578
Rock's Backpages
by Philip Norman (1970)
191
Sound Check
by Yahoo! Music Canada
27
Stop The Presses!
by Us Magazine
85
That's Really Week
by Lyndsey Parker
124
The Blender Burner
by Blender Magazine
27
The MOJO Blog
by Bill DeMain
88
The NME Blog
by Luke Lewis
48
The Spin Blog
by David Marchese
77
The Ten
by Andy West
9
Video Ga Ga
by Lyndsey Parker
70

Lambert says he got carried away, but not sorry

AP
Wed Nov 25, 2009 11:00am PST

AP - Adam Lambert admits he got carried away with his sexually charged American Music Awards performance, but he's offering no apology. The glam rocker from "American Idol" said on "The Early Show" t… More »

More News Stories