Yahoo! Services

Account Options

New User? Sign Up Sign In Help

Yahoo! Search

Music Blogs

The Ten Most Loved And Hated Performers

Posted Tue Feb 17, 2009 12:04pm PST by Rob O'Connor in List Of The Day
Certain performers evoke strong reactions either positive or negative--as if you're not allowed to be neutral. You must decide--or else. Why? Sometimes it's the performer who's just so in your face. Sometimes it's the artist's audience whose devotion makes you wonder if you tripped upon a cult. Sometimes it's even the actual music that's tailored to a certain audience and feels exclusionary to everyone else.

I've been writing this blog for what now has been about half my life. And I've learned, too, that certain bands have computer savvy fans quick to defend their idols, while other performers aren't quite so lucky. I've been dogging on the Pure Prairie League and it's as if no one cares! While I've been surprised by just how many Leon Russell fans are still alive and well and ready to stick up for their man. And Aerosmith fans are a vocal lot, while the enthusiasm for Uriah Heep hasn't quite kept up with the times.

And I am planning a list of the Ten Most Universally Loved Bands as well. Which, of course, will bring an outpouring of people letting us all know how much they don't love said bands. But that's the beauty of this whole schoolyard-sandbox! Everyone gets to play. Just don't knock me in the head with the metal shovel. Those things hurt.

10) Creed: Scott Stapp always looks so serious. Which only sets you up for being goofed on. And the fact that the band's music sounds big and important and makes Pearl Jam sound modest in comparison makes them ripe for ribbing. But their fans are solid, true believers and made them one of the era's most successful bands. Had they stayed together would they have saved or destroyed civilization? We now will never know.

9) Sonic Youth: When they opened for Neil Young back in the early ‘90s, Sonic Youth were suddenly thrust into the classic rock spotlight where their alternate tunings and indie-rock mutterings were suddenly cooked under the mainstream microscope. What made sense to people used to loitering in dark, dirty rock clubs was suddenly being served to the day-glo beer bracelet crowd and the results wasn't always pretty. Yes, the professional reviews have been pretty glowing, but it only seemed to breed resentment in other quarters where the band have been considered a tuneless fraud. Different strokes for different folks could've been the band's motto if it wasn't already a tired cliché.

8) U2: No matter how many times Bono tries to tell a joke or show off his light-hearted side, it still comes off as if he's merely stooping down to say hello to the little people. He's always insisted on indulging his flair for the dramatic and his band either play anthemic rock that makes you want to topple the castle walls or sleep-inducing drones that lack any jam-kicking drive. They're a bit like a religion. Their followers see a Messiah leading them to the promised land and their detractors see a snake-oil salesman hocking overpriced goo.

7) Rush: Let's hear it from the ladies in the audience! Oh, wait, there aren't any. This is a RUSH concert. The only women in attendance were dragged there by boyfriends who are skating on some pretty thin ice. I'm sure a handful of female Rush fans will write in to correct me on this point. But, really, take a look around. For whatever reason, Rush attract a predominately male audience who admire and analyze the band's every move. It's like a secret language where science fiction, objectivism and weird time signatures all converge and plan to sprout a new society. To outsiders, it's like Geek-A-Thon 2112 where Daffy Duck sings the company song for two hours.

6) Jimmy Buffett: Parrotheads can't get enough and have made Jimmy Buffett one of the richest, most successful performers of the past century. The man has his appeal. But to those not swayed by the pirate's life and who've never ventured down to the Florida Keys, the whole experience looks more like an insurance convention gone loco. 

5) Barbra Streisand: Could her following be much larger? She crosses over to so many different audiences who would pay any amount of money to hear her sing, to perform, to lift their spirits. And there are other people who would pay any amount of money to NOT hear her sing another note. One man's ceiling is another man's floor? One man's junk is another man's treasure? One man's daughter is another's man's annoying next door neighbor?

4) The Doors: I've never quite understood this, but it started in college and has followed me everywhere I write. Anytime I write about the Doors, it leads to people vehemently discussing how much Jim Morrison a) sucks, b) rules. If I say something positive, it's not positive enough. If I write something negative, I'm not nasty enough. Either Jimmy and the boys were genius or they were pretentious creeps who had the blues. Heck, my own problem is I like the pretentiousness and the drunken vocals. Those are the good parts in my book.

3) Billy Joel: The man has more songs on the radio than just about any performer I can name. Many people swear he's written the soundtrack to their lives. Many other people wish they could live in a world where never would another Billy Joel song visit their lives. It's like they should start planning retirement communities where you could decide whether you want to live the Billy Joel lifestyle or the Non-Billy Joel Lifestyle, the way they once offered Smoking or Non-smoking sections of a restaurant. It only seems fair.

2) Frank Zappa: His admirers laugh at his jokes and admire his musicianship--and collect an awful lot of albums. His detractors think he's smarmy, self-congratulatory and not nearly as smart as he thinks he is--and they don't collect a lot of his albums. Some people think he's funny looking--or that he named his kids some pretty freaky names--Dweezil?, Moon Unit? He was a true original. You just have to decide whether his distinct flavor and aroma is right for you. Somebody uses the Boysenberry syrup at the IHOP.

1) Grateful Dead: This one should be obvious. Deadheads are legion and they can discuss the variations of the different performances and they have the bootlegs to back up their theories. To those not turned on and tuned in to their trip, it just looks like a parking lot with no designated parking spots and too much mud to ever be bothered. Do you need to be high to "get it"? I can't tell. But the people seem to be having a good time. But it could all be a ruse of the CIA setting us up for a cataclysmic disaster. You decide if it's worth the risk.

167 Comments

1. DUDE -
Excellent list!...Most people either love or hate these artists...Apparently,they are doing something right.

2. Yahoo! Music User -
May I ask you any of these singers are?

the only 2 i might have heard anything about is U2 or Jimmy Buffett

3. pjlawrence81 -
You forgot Nickelback. All I read about is how much they suck, but they sell bajillions of records, so somebody likes them. Metallica could be on this list, too. They have their legion of die-hard fans, and they have their haters who have to play the "sell-out" card every 5 years or so.

4. pha-q-did -
I like 50% of the groups on the list and hate the other half. But you could throw out ten other various groups and the result whould probably be about the same. The point is you have no point. It true for every artist or group; some people will like them and ours won't...Thanks for obvious.

5. Yahoo! Music User -
The Dead, U2 and Zappa are all cultist. You either get them or you don't. The devotion of the fans makes objective conversation impossible. Parrotheads are Deadheads using less psycho active drugs, and more attractive looking when they go topless. Babs has the Oprah/Obama personality driven hype thing going. In very controlled enviroments they can do their act other wise look out below. Rush is an excuse for Canadains to express angst about being born a little to far north.

Great List!!!

6. __A_YAHOO_USER__ -
Okay, first of Rob (You always read MY comments, right?), you took away my "Where is Rush" line...LAME!

Anyways,Pjlawrance, Nickelback is more or less a different incarnation of Creed. The only difference to me is that Nickelback is vulgar and that

1 Creed song makes me want to go to sleep and 1 Nickelback song makes me want to cry over what happened to hair metal (yes, I actually WANT hair metal back!).

As for Metallica, he has a point Rob...maybe honorable mention?

Ah, yeah, nice list Rob, seems you covered most of the bases...
(#4 missed the whole point, haha!).



Just one addition:

Cute Is What We Aim For.

MAN! Do labels LOVE THEM or not? Do kids and teenagers love them or WHAT!?

But...is their music any good? I say: NO!




Finally, ROB YOU MUST READ THIS!

I ACTUALLY LIKE THE PURE PRARIE LEAGUE! I'M A FAN.

Now, I don't recall reading anything in which you bashed them, but if you did, I'd be sure to tell you otherwise. So there. Somone cares.

7. The Great Claudini -
Pure Prarie Leauge?

8. nova1mom -
Nice job on the list! My personal add-on would be Neil Diamond. Never could understand his appeal, but I know they are many who love him.

9. mbee -
The Buffett Genre is, "Drunk, Caribbean Rock and Roll Escapism" Don't knock it till you try it.......Life on a Sailboat with suntan oil, Bikini's and warm places, fueled with Rum and or Tequila. YES, I have been there!

10. JenniferJ -
I had never considered that Rush was a geeky guys' band....I hesitate to state it as I don't think there's anything THAT geeky about them, yet I am a "literate" female...perhaps it's the literate appeal...the bit you described, science fiction,time changes, objectivism I am blissfully unaware of as Rush attractions.....for me anyway, it is more just a compelling insight whether it's into "Subdivisions" or the lovely "tom Sawyer" "Sprit of the Radio" I just think it's so smart and spot on in describing realities that most rock songs can't even touch....and the musicianship is well, peerless...how about the comparison to Radiohead...only more 70s, more American and less isolated...oh I don't know.....enjoyed your list though!

11. Kermit -
Good list. I just wonder why Marilyn Manson was left off?

12. Quiznos -
Creed loves racism and rape.

13. DiamondGirl -
Good list. Parrotheads are a different breed than most..you have to embrace the lifestyle a little to understand it.
***as for the comment: "Who are these singers?"..umm..are you kidding? Apparently, you have led a sheltered life somewhere...

14. Trin -
I'm a girl and I like Rush! Then again, I'm also a geeky girl. That probably explains it. Zappa is awesome too. I just bought The Mothers Live At Fillmore East and it's amazing. Especially 'Do You Like My New Car?'

15. Trin -
I'm a girl and I like Rush! Then again, I'm also a geeky girl. That probably explains it. Zappa is awesome too. I just bought The Mothers Live At Fillmore East and it's amazing. Especially 'Do You Like My New Car?'

16. Nekoburger -
I hate The Grateful Dead the most out of all bands ever. You left out The Beatles. It's pretty safe to say everybody loves them. I don't trust a person who says they don't like the Beatles. I've only met 2 people in my life who say they don't like them. I just sit there and I can't get my head around it.

17. Slaytanic -
How about Elvis, you either love him or hate him..(Much love to the King for your truly)

How about Van Halen? Many people love that corporate crap, but I hate it.

As for Metallica they rule. How many bands can say they had a gold records with no airplay and corporate backing.. Kill em All rocks!!!

18. Yahoo! Music User -
Love and hate, good versus evil, summer and winter.......I see where this is going.....

19. mikez34 -
Good list, it's hard for a band to have such viceral love and hate at the same time. Creed would have been much higher on my list. I hate them so much. I haven't heard that many people complain about Rush, so I guess that is the only band I don't understand being on this list.

My only addition would be Pearl Jam.

20. Karen -
Creed: Meh.
Sonic Youth: I only know one song by them, and I hate it.
U2: Like 'em, don't love 'em, don't hate 'em.
Rush: LOVE 'em (and I'm a girl), particularly the "weird time signatures".
Jimmy Buffett: Meh. Like "Fins"; that's about it. I just hate that Kenny Chesney thinks he's Buffett, Jr.
Barbra Streisand: The first record I ever owned was "People" when I was 3...and I still have it! Love her voice. Hate her politics.
Doors: They're OK.
Billy Joel: Love him. In the song "Little Goodbyes" by SheDaisy, there is a line, "I took the Beatles; left Billy Joel" that always cracks me up.
Frank Zappa: Not versed enough on him to form an honest opinion.
Grateful Dead: The only one on this list that I actively despise; but, of course, I've never done drugs.
Page:  1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 
Leave Your Comment
You must sign in to leave a comment
Select a Blog Posts
New This Week
by Dave DiMartino
123
Reality Bites
by Jordan Gracey
38
Reality Rocks
by Lyndsey Parker
579
Rock's Backpages
by Philip Norman (1970)
191
Sound Check
by Yahoo! Music Canada
27
Stop The Presses!
by Us Magazine
85
That's Really Week
by Lyndsey Parker
124
The Blender Burner
by Blender Magazine
27
The MOJO Blog
by Bill DeMain
88
The NME Blog
by Luke Lewis
48
The Spin Blog
by David Marchese
77
The Ten
by Andy West
9
Video Ga Ga
by Lyndsey Parker
70

Lambert says he got carried away, but not sorry

AP
Wed Nov 25, 2009 11:00am PST

AP - Adam Lambert admits he got carried away with his sexually charged American Music Awards performance, but he's offering no apology. The glam rocker from "American Idol" said on "The Early Show" t… More »

More News Stories